A powerful silence reigns in the paintings of Sidney Goodman, paintings packed with the drama of what is left unsaid. His work is steeped in the perfectionism that is part of Philadelphia's grand figurative tradition, developed over the course of previous centuries by such masters as Charles Willson Peale and Thomas Eakins. But Goodman has directed his powers of observation and verisimilitude to uniquely expressive and metaphorical ends, singularly relevant to his own time and place. Rarely looking beyond his own family and friends, neighborhood, or the newspaper for inspiration for figures and settings, the artist has found the basic ordinariness of his subject matter integral to the air of disquiet produced by his paintings.
Although the title of the work gives no such indication, this painting is a portrait of Goodman's family. The artist's intimacy with his sitters is nowhere in evidence, as they occupy distinct portions of the monumental canvas, absorbed in their wholly separate mental and physical spaces. The dark shadows slicing the landscape and the ominous clouds gathering overhead provide an unambiguously foreboding mood. Goodman's paintings bring to light the grotesque element of the everyday furnishings of people's lives. Here, for example, the thick red rubber Hippity Hop toy that was a ubiquitous element of American childhood in the late 1960s and early 1970s becomes a monstrous adjunct to the little girl sitting on it, virtually attached to her as its red joins the white and blue of her clothing. Goodman adamantly denies that his paintings are designed to communicate a specific message. It is nonetheless difficult to contemplate this family without finding within it the full spectrum of sociopolitical traumas that pummeled the American psyche in the early 1970s. Twentieth Century Painting and Sculpture in the Philadelphia Museum of Art (2000), p. 122.